Advertisement

My “Learner” AR

My versatile, shape-shifting Learner AR — with friend.

I dragged my nearly ten year-old “Learner” AR out of the safe this week and took it to sight-in at the range. The reasons for this are convoluted. Allow me to explain.

First of all, with deer rifle season approaching, recall that the family property that I have hunted previously is across state lines.

There is a new edict from his majesty the state governor that  visitors to that state need a negative COVID test to go there. Now, if I were going to simply go and sit in the woods by myself and then return home I truly wouldn’t worry about it. I sincerely doubt that any game wardens are going to ask to see my test results. But it’s a five hour round trip to the property and back. I don’t think I’ve ever made that trip without needing a coffee stop (or a coffee-offloading stop). That would require people contact – at least minimally.

Beyond the governmental overreach, I’m just not feeling the five hour round trip this year. If I want a full day in the woods, that travel time makes things onerous unless I get a hotel room and stay overnight. In which case I would have even more human contact and would thus feel even more obligation to get COVID tested – because we are still seeing patients face-to-face in the office, and who knows if I saw someone who was asymptomatic or pre-symptomatic? Except the testing site lines have been running down the street and around the corner for the past week. Thus, testing is not an easy thing to accomplish currently. (No, we don’t have testing in my own office)

So I said screw it – I’ll stay home and try state game lands outside town instead. Except that this was an unexpected last minute decision, so I haven’t put up a blind and will likely be just moving around and sitting on a stool periodically. It’s sort of hunting via walkabout. But honestly I have seen more deer over the years on walkabout than I have the few times I sat in a designated blind. This is how my family hunts, and I get bored in a blind anyway.

I love the Aero Precision .308 I built last year, and while it’s fantastic for a stationary blind-hunt (the meat in my freezer confirms this), it’s a little heavy for walkabout hunting.

So I decided to take my “Learner” AR out of the safe. It’s a bit of a shape-shifter, because before more recent purchases it was my jack-of-all-trades AR that I used for everything.

Allow me to go over the sequence of events in my AR history…

I attended my first Babes With Bullets rifle camp in Spring 2011. I had been shooting a handgun for two years at that point. That camp hooked me into wanting an AR of my own, so I started researching, asking for advice, and looking around as soon as I got home. Bear in mind that the so-called Assault Weapons Ban had been allowed to sunset in 2004, so there was seven years’ worth of new offerings to wade through, but not nearly the choices there are now.

Babes With Bullets 2011 – where I learned that I wanted my own AR platform rifle.

I ultimately settled on an S&W M&P15 TS. That was my first AR, and the one that got me started in 3-Gun. A couple years later I won a rifle in a raffle to use for 3-Gun, so my M&P became my learner gun in a different way. It became the gun that I learned to do modifications on.

I played with colorizing the stamping with nail polish – first one color, then another. Then I learned how to swap out the pistol grip at my kitchen table. Then I learned how to change the factory stock for one that I had won from a match prize table. Then I learned how to install a drop-in trigger group.

From pink…
… To FDE color scheme – I learned to do it myself.
Then I learned to swap out the trigger.

After all that work, I wanted to shoot her some more, so I got a 22 adapter from CMMG and used my M&P to shoot rimfire steel matches for a couple seasons. That was a ton of fun and allowed my baby to not sit lonely in the safe.

Then one day I got the itch to shoot a larger caliber. I found out that .300BLK could still use a standard AR lower and magazines. Nowadays there are dedicated .300 BLK magazines, but at the time I was looking for as much versatility and dual use as possible. Not feeling brave enough to build an entire upper yet at the time, I ordered one from Stag arms.

There was a bit of a saga with the delivery of said upper. Suffice to say that it involved the UPS dispatcher giving me the driver’s cell# and me chasing the Big Brown Truck of (un)Happiness down country lanes at dusk in the rain on a Friday evening. The only thing missing was the “Yackety Sax” soundtrack from Benny Hill.

Alas after all that drama, the state where family property is located doesn’t allow semi-auto for deer, so this .300 BLK upper from Stag has never gotten to stretch its legs in the field. My Aero has been blooded in Texas – but this gun has not.

So I took my first AR friend to the range to sight her in this week. She didn’t need it even though the upper had been removed and put back on again. The Nikon 1-4 (my first 3-Gun scope) was still good enough at 100 yards for a kill shot. Five rounds and I was done. I am not a precision kind of gal. If it’s good enough for several hits in the heart/lung zone off hand I am happy. 

Off to the range!

The upside to staying at home to hunt this year is that my state DOES allow semi-auto -including AR platform – for big game. In fact, I “could” legally use 5.56 for hunting here, but I just don’t want to do that. In addition, my state has easier regs for antlerless tags and very little in the way of antler restrictions. The huge drawback from my perspective is that I am limited to public game lands and I am a female hunting alone. Maybe that shouldn’t be an impediment, but I have allowed it to be in the past.

Nonetheless, I’m going to do it anyway. There are two tracts of Wildlife Management Area that I have looked at in the past that are only about a 20 minute drive away, so I am going to try. I haven’t scouted enough to set up a blind, so I’m going to look at it as a walk in the woods with a gun and we’ll see what happens. If nothing else I’ll get some fresh air and my learner gun will get some much deserved field time. I think we both need a breather in the woods, whether we get to actually shoot or not. That’s the plan – we’ll see what happens.

AR-15 Breakdown – Rifles, Pistols, Firearms

U.S. Firearms laws are a substantial godforsaken mess. Most of them rarely make sense, and firearms manufacturers are smarter than lawmakers and often find a way around silly rules. The AR-15 is America’s favorite gun, and why not? It’s modular, easy to use, lightweight, accurate, and capable. It’s so popular it comes in a variety of configurations—some for particular purposes and others to fit legal definitions. Today we are going to do a AR-15 breakdown and explain the various legal definitions and how they apply to the AR-15 platform. 

AR-15 Breakdown 101 – The Rifle 

The most common and most basic configuration of the AR-15 is the rifle variant. AR-15 rifles in the United States must meet a few pieces of legal criteria. First and foremost, a rifle in the United States has a barrel length of at least 16 inches and a shoulder stock. Any shorter of a barrel, and you have a short-barreled rifle, which we’ll talk about a little later. 

In the AR world, the 16-inch barrel carbine variant is the most common but not the only option. Shooters can utilize a 14.5-inch barrel and permanently affix a muzzle device that extends the barrel to 16 inches, the permanent length of the barrel assembly, not the rifled portion is what is legally important. AR-15 rifles can use vertical grips without legal issues either. 

The Pistol 

AR-15 pistols are AR-15s without a stock and a barrel shorter than 16 inches. AR-15 pistols exist because people want AR-15s shorter than rifles and do not want to deal with the NFA, or people want to build an SBR after following the ATF’s stringent NFA process. 

There is no set barrel length, and an AR pistol can have as short of a barrel or overall length as you desire. If the pistol is longer than 26 inches, it could be an ‘other firearm’, which we’ll address next. You can attach a brace to a AR-15 pistol to make such a heavy pistol easier to handle. However, you cannot do so with the intent to shoulder the brace. 

The SAINT Pistol

One weird part of this AR-15 breakdown has a lot to do with vertical grips. An AR pistol can not have a vertical grip but can have an angled grip. It’s a weird rule, but many of the ATF rules are funny. It goes back to the NFA.

AR-15 pistols are legally pistols, and this often changes state laws regarding them. The different laws could be required waiting periods, the age to purchase the weapon, and more. It’s not all bad news as AR-15 pistols can be concealed or carried loaded and ready in a vehicle in some states where doing the same with a rifle is not allowed. 

The ‘Firearm’ 

All AR-15s are firearms, right? Well, yeah, that’s true, but Firearm or Other is a category for weapons that fall outside of normal categories of pistol, rifle, and shotgun. For example, the Mossberg Shockwave is not a shotgun, but a firearm. For this AR-15 breakdown, we are going to focus on AR-15 firearms. 

A Franklin Armory Firearm

AR-15 firearms do not have a standard for barrel length but must be over 26 inches long in its smallest configuration. You cannot attach a stock to an AR firearm. An AR-15 firearm could have a stabilizing brace, and if it’s the adjustable model, it will be measured with the brace collapsed. 

Another Franklin Armory Firearm

The big difference between AR firearms and AR pistols is the ability to attach a vertical grip. That often defines what an AR firearm is versus what an AR pistol is. AR firearms are regulated differently as well, and you lose the legal benefits of an AR pistol. The benefits of an AR firearm are rare and typically allow shooters to avoid onerous state assault weapon bans. Kits like the Franklin Armory California Compliant Kit is one such example. 

The Short Barreled Rifle

Our last firearm in this AR breakdown is the Short Barreled rifle, or SBR. SBRs are Title 2 firearms and require a tax stamp and permission from your Majesty (the ATF.) SBRs have a stock and a barrel length of fewer than 16 inches. You can even attach a vertical grip to the thing. 

Short barreled rifles are the wild west, except you have to purchase a ticket before you can jump on the Oregon Trail. Some states do not allow the ownership of SBRs, so it may not even be an option for you, depending on state laws. 

You can purchase a pre-built AR SBR or manufacture your own. Either way, you have some paperwork to do, and a two hundred dollar tax stamp to pay, and NFA laws to deal with. 

The Many Faces of An AR-15 

The popularity of the AR-15 is unlikely to be matched in my lifetime. You can assemble one, build an 80 percent lower model, or buy one. The fact that four different legal configurations exist shows just how popular the platform is. Hopefully, this AR-15 breakdown has helped you understand the different pros and cons of each configuration and maybe even helped you choose the right configuration(s) for your wants and needs. 

Wear Anything and Carry – The PHLster ENIGMA

I’m just going to let you hit play on this one and let Jon and Sarah show you.

They have broken the code, cracked the matrix, shaken the very foundations of the internet (in firearms circles anyway) with a product that will make EDC easy and more universal like never previously seen.

SIG ZULU6 Gimbal Stabilized Binos

This is some straight Star Wars optics tech that I’m happy to announce someone put into place. Image stabilized binoculars. We’ve been able to do it for phones and cameras now forever and but the natural movements of the body are what they are through straight glass.

The stable smooth panning shots we see in film of a character using binos are utter bullshit. Ask anyone who has ever used binos. They respond to every twitch, muscle tremor, inhalation, exhalation, and heart beat of the person holding them up. Using the same technology we’ve already put into place for image stabilization in other mediums, SIG has smoothed out these issues.

From SIG:

NEWINGTON, N.H., (November 20, 2020) – SIG SAUER Electro-Optics is pleased to introduce the ZULU6 image stabilized binoculars to the ZULU series of binoculars.  The ZULU6 binoculars feature Optical Image Stabilization (OIS) technology which utilizes an electronically stabilized 2-axis gimbal system to cancel out vibration caused by buffeting wind, chop and waves on the water, washboard ranch roads, heartbeat, heavy breathing and shaking.

“The SIG SAUER image stabilizing technology was introduced several years ago in our OSCAR3 compact spotting scope, and we’re excited to integrate this incredible technology into the new and affordable ZULU6 binoculars said Andy York, President, SIG SAUER Electro-Optics.  “Most binocular brands have been chasing that last degree of optical resolution and frankly vibration cancels that resolution out, the new OIS technology allows for crystal-clear handheld viewing with stunning image quality, once you use this new tech, you will not go back to traditional binoculars”  

The SIG SAUER Electro-Optics ZULU6 Image Stabilized Binoculars feature patented optical image stabilization (OIS) technology, SPECTRACOAT™, LENSHIELD™, and LENSARMOR™ coatings, MOTAC™ (motion activated illumination), an IPX4 waterproof rating for use in wet weather environments, and are available in 10x30mm and 16x42mm magnification.

The SIG SAUER Electro-Optics ZULU6 Image Stabilizing Binoculars are now available for purchase in retail stores and at sigsauer.com.

ZULU6 10x30mm Binocular Specs:
Magnification: 10x
Objective Diameter: 30mm
Field of View: 5.2 degrees
Eye Relief: 15mm
Battery: CR2
Waterproof: IPX4
Overall Length: 5.9 in.
Overall Height: 4.7 in.
Overall Width: 1.9 in.
Weight: 18.6 oz.

Part Number: SOZ61001 MSRP: $799.99

ZULU6 16x42mm Binocular Specs:
Magnification: 16x
Objective Diameter: 42mm
Field of View: 3.8 degrees
Eye Relief: 14mm
Battery: AA
Waterproof: IPX4
Overall Length: 7.1 in.
Overall Height: 4.7 in.
Overall Width: 2.8 in.
Weight: 20 oz.

Part Number: SOZ61601 MSRP: $899.99

About SIG SAUER, Inc.
SIG SAUER, Inc. is a leading provider and manufacturer of firearms, electro-optics, ammunition, airguns, suppressors, and training. For over 250 years SIG SAUER, Inc. has evolved, and thrived, by blending American ingenuity, German engineering, and Swiss precision.  Today, SIG SAUER is synonymous with industry-leading quality and innovation which has made it the brand of choice amongst the U.S. Military, the global defense community, law enforcement, competitive shooters, hunters, and responsible citizens.  Additionally, SIG SAUER is the premier provider of elite firearms instruction and tactical training at the SIG SAUER Academy.  Headquartered in Newington, New Hampshire, SIG SAUER has over 2,300 employees across nine locations.  For more information about the company and product line visit: sigsauer.com.

EOTech’s New 5x and Micro 3x Magnifiers

The G45 and G43 (not the Glocks) are the latest in red dot and holographic optical enhancement magnifiers from arguably the guys who made the best/clearest 3x. Magnifiers are a love them/hate them type addition in many instances. Due to the nature of the focal planes and image gathering they have to work with they tend to have short eye relief. But the ability to slide a magnifier into position for zeroing, refinement, or longer shots are all fantastic benefits.

Here is EOTech’s release:

Ann Arbor, MI (November 20, 2020) Reach out and touch something with a rugged and performance driven EOTECH® Magnifier. Providing a perfect match for an EOTECH Holographic Weapon Sight (HWS), the G43 or G45 Magnifiers transforms them into a lethal, medium-range optic.

New in 2020, the G45 5X Magnifier has similar weight and dimensions as the existing G33 Magnifier, but with an additional 2X magnification for precision aiming at greater distances. The Shift-To-Side (STS) mount provides fast transitioning from 5X to 1X and the optic offers tool-free vertical and horizontal adjustments with a large field-of-view. The G45 works with all EOTECH HWS models and other red dots offering co-witness or lower 1/3 co-witness heights.

The G43 magnifier is a miniaturized version of EOTECH’s battle tested G33, making it one of the most compact and lightweight magnifiers on the market today. Like the G45, the G43 is wrapped in a ruggedized rubber overmold for added durability and includes a 7mm spacer for different height configurations.  

“A significant advantage is gained when using a magnifier behind a holographic sight.  Because the HWS is powered by a laser diode, and not an LED, the dot size stays 1MOA, with the magnifier in place, while the target gets 3-5 times bigger.” Said Mark Miller, EOTECH Product Manager.  “When using a magnifier behind an LED red dot, the dot size grows at the same rate as the target, so no increased precision is recognized.”

Both the G43 and G45 are backed by EOTECH’s Prestige Warranty that guarantees every product to be free from manufacturing defects in material and workmanship under normal use for a period of ten (10) years from the manufacturer’s date or customer’s proof of purchase.

Technical Specifications G45.STS

  • Fixed Magnification: 5X
  • Eye Relief: 2.6″ (67 mm)
  • Field of View: 4.4°
  • Length: 3.9″
  • Width: 2.3″
  • Height: 3.3″
  • Features: Fog resistant; comes with quick-detach mount.
  • MSRP: $669

Technical Specifications G43.STS

  • Magnification: 3X
  • Eye Relief: 2.5″ (64 mm)
  • Field of View: 7.5°
  • Length: 3.1″ 
  • Width: 2.3″
  • Height: 3.3″
  • Features: Fog resistant; comes with quick-detach mount.
  • MSRP: $629

About EOTECH®
Headquartered in Ann Arbor, Michigan, EOTECH designs, manufactures and markets electro-optical products, Vudu rifle optics, thermal devices, and night vision systems. Due to its advanced technology, EOTECH Holographic Weapon Sights (HWS) are among the fastest and most intuitive sighting systems on the planet. This is exactly why you’ll find them on the weapons of America’s most elite law enforcement professionals and special operations warriors. You’ll immediately see the advantage the instant you engage a target. www.eotechinc.com

About this paragraph though…

“A significant advantage is gained when using a magnifier behind a holographic sight.  Because the HWS is powered by a laser diode, and not an LED, the dot size stays 1MOA, with the magnifier in place, while the target gets 3-5 times bigger.” Said Mark Miller, EOTECH Product Manager.  “When using a magnifier behind an LED red dot, the dot size grows at the same rate as the target, so no increased precision is recognized.”

This is what we call “clever marketing”. The implied meaning is that the EOTech’s dot gets more precise when magnified. That isn’t what is said though. It is stated that the dot “remains 1 MOA” which is the most precise red dot point commercially, EOTech by default is the more precise aiming point and the hologram makes it nearly parallax free. They didn’t say the dot doesn’t get bigger, they say the dot remains 1 MOA, but as we know from how front focal plane systems work (which is what a RDS/Holo and magnifier set up is emulating) the reticle scales with the target image to remain 1 MOA.

The implied meaning, without lying, is that the red dot LED optics will bloom when magnified, and this is true to a degree. Especially if the LED is turned up to a high brightness, the dot will be more than its prescribed 2 MOA. 2, being already twice the size of 1, will cover twice the area under magnification, and more than that if turned up brighter.

But getting back to that implied meaning you might get the impression that the dot exploded in size to 6 or 10 or umpteen MOA instead of remaining 2 when the magnifier is in place. That is not the case, it is still 2 or roughly 2 MOA, but it was already larger than the EOTech’s 1 MOA, might be turned overly bright for magnification and is projecting larger than 2, and the image just multiplied by 3, 5, or 6 times depending on your magnifier. This will result in a bloom effect that is startling and more dramatic than the EOTech’s precise 1 MOA aiming point which, is probably best appreciated with magnification.

So, for clarity, all dot reticles get “bigger” when magnified, by precisely the amount they are magnified.

Holographic reticles accomplish this cleanest because they are the most precise from the start.

Feeling ‘Triggered’ Are We?

One of the most interesting features of the P320 MHS (Modular Handgun System) was… well… the modularity. Now modularity is an overused buzzword that basically means you can change stuff around fairly easily if you want to spend the time, effort, and money.

But it opened the door to an interesting possibility that I am pleased to see SIG now offering.

Made. To. Order.

SIG Custom works has launched a Fire Control Unit studio. Basically a ‘construct a plush stuffed animal’ for the P320 trigger mechanism that you can then add your favorite(s) in slide, optics, and frame too for a tailored pistol on standardized parts.

The FCU is the legal firearm, the serialized item for the handgun (or it could be rifle, firearm, SBR, AOW, SBS, or shotgun depending, I saw some prototypes that looked interesting) and you can pick frame, barrel, caliber, and optics suite from the booming buffet of options.

Let’s be honest. “Modular” doesn’t mean a whole lot practically in many respects. All the “modular” rifle options have quietly solidified into SKUs, factory options instead of end an user owned pile of parts that you magic into the ninjafied mission specific rifle and then reninjafy on the fly. However, the P320 has defied that stereotype with a couple key elements now offered. First, factory and aftermarket grips, slides, and sights are available and affordable at a variety of levels and features. Second, the pistol is incredibly easy to work this feature on. Pulling the FCU and putting it into a new frame was simple. Making owning a ‘gamer’ and/or ‘duty’ and/or ‘concealed carry’ frame all very easy and practical options.

If you don’t need the option, you don’t. But for those that benefitted from it, the ease of use compounded the benefit.

So now the option has come into its next logical phase, the made to order FCU where instead of buying stock and modding (which you can still absolutely do if you enjoy it) you can pick your preferred parts and order it to arrive instead.

SIG’s release below:

With its unprecedented modularity and unmatched capability, the P320 platform has become one of the most exciting pistols available to firearms enthusiasts today. The soul of the P320 and the driving force behind its modularity lies in the unique, patented design of its Fire Control Unit (FCU).

Now you can build your dream pistol from the ground up. The Custom Works FCU lets you create like never before. Countless options, endless possibilities.

LAUNCH THE P320 STUDIO

When the AK is Definitively A-Okay – The ACE

The IWI Galil ACE in any of its 4 available calibers is arguably one of the greatest modern evolutions of the Kalashnikov (and Garand) platforms.

Improved “westernized” ergonomics and in both pistol (for now) and rifle formats and in both comm-bloc and both NATO calibers the ACE is an ACE in the space.

Henry and Josh take it through the 9-Hole course and it delivers a fantastic run in 7.62×39, a caliber not known for its beyond 300 meter performance. Of all four major calibers it becomes the most atmospheric sensitive the earliest, which isn’t surprising considering it is the slowest and has a lackluster ballistic coefficient.

[NOTE: Yes, Henry improperly states that the ACE has a NON-reciprocating charging handle. This is in error. It doesn’t influence the result.]

The ACE pistols are fun compact little firecrackers and the rifles are solid well thought out performers. But my favorite variants of the ACE are foreign only (right now) because they sport the 13″ barrels.

11.5-14.5″ carbines are all the rage in 2020 as folks have tried the various lengths ballistics in the various chamberings and it seems to hit that happy balance of all relevant factors. It’s sized well to use in and around limited space environments like hallways and vehicles. It still provides enough barrel to achieve acceptable ballistics and not be too ‘flashy’ at the muzzle if not running suppressed. Speaking of that they run well suppressed, are easy to gas properly, and are still maintain a fairly small profile with modern cans. It’s the ‘sweet spot’ of rifles, although more along the lines of a ‘sweet zone’ since the variables are… well… variable.

The ACE is easily arguable as the best AK variant for a whole host of reasons. It tracks well in modern ergonomics, modern compatibility, ease of maintenance, reliability, accuracy, and cost. You can get a decent bone stock AK for less than an ACE but getting one that is set up with the factory provided enhancements that the ACE has usually runs you quite a bit more.

The Rifle Dynamics, Krebs, or Fuller, rifles are going to be phenomenally built and run well. But so is the ACE. I love my RD, its a great rifle I have no plans to part with. But if I was given the option of “AKs” off a table, the Beryl, AK12/15, Krebs, RD, Arsenal AK20, etc. and told to kit one out for serious use it would be the ACE. Access to the aftermarket? Still the ACE.

The Sportiest of Cookouts

It’s a trope seen in many a comedy sketch of an action movie or western. A round of ammunition literally “cooking” off. The bullet then comically cascades around the immediate environment wreaking havoc but generally only causing comical injuries and the most minor of damage as it pings off pots and pans and eventually boops someone in the buttocks.

Hilarious.

And like many a Hollywood firearm faux pas… Completely against the laws of physics. As Brandon demonstrates in the video, macro laws of physics are still in place when it comes to firearms. Firearms run on these laws. Everything we developed to make firearms run as they do is because of our understanding of physics, from simple leverage, to heat and pressure, to fluid dynamics and atmospherics.

Grade School Physics Lesson

The reason the bullet goes down the barrel as the gas from the burning powder expands is because, when it is encased in the steel of the chamber and bolt, the barrel is the path of least resistance. Pressure seeks and takes that path of least resistance.

In open air the path of least resistance isn’t defined by the steel walls of the chamber and bolt face. It is instead defined by the fact that the bullet is the heaviest and most dense piece, and thus an ‘anchor point’ and the ground or any solid surface the case might be resting against. Including the charcoal in this case which is also providing ignition heat instead of a direct spark. So the grain of powder that hits ignition temperature first will start the reaction little more chaotically than a primer.

All this to say that essentially you have a brass or steel bodied fire-cracker and not a device that will throw a bullet. The bullet is the mass keeping it in place most solidly in fact. It is the metallic case that makes the round a hazard still at close distance. The metal is being heated unevenly and is not supported so it is going to split, possibly fragment, and jump wherever it has the energy to get to with the escaping gas. Not at X,000 feet per second, but with enough spice to cause lacerations in soft exposed tissues. The eyeballs are probably at greatest risk of severe injury as they are a highly vulnerably piece of anatomy to any small flying bits.

All of these facets are why fireworks use paper and cardboard as their sealing systems in many cases, those do not turn into flying bits of metal which reduces the number of sources that can cause injury to just the burning compounds and the raw force of the detonation/gas expansion.

Dangerous?

“Risky” I think is the more accurate term. Dangerous implies an unacceptable under all circumstances level of risk, although not strictly meaning that. “Risky” implies a moderate level of risk where injury or damage could occur but can be easily mitigated or accepted as the situation may allow or dictate necessary. There is overlap and subjective personal biases and all that but all in all risk here is mitigated quite a bit by distance and effectively eliminated by an imposed barrier (hill)

Still. Cool physics. Despite the fact that at today’s rates Brandon burned about $55.76 (rounded up) in a fire for science.

Dr. Michael Siegel & DRGO

(from dreamsmoke.com)

This piece is a disappointment. You’ll see.

I ran across an interview in late September on RecoilTV by BJ Campbell (also a writer for OpenSourceDefense, which we share on DRGO Facebook weekly). I couldn’t identify its date, but it appeared to be recent. He talked with Michael Siegel, MD, MPH of Boston University’s School of Public Health, whom Campbell names “one of the pre-eminent gun policy researchers in the world”.

Dr. Siegel is prominent enough that DRGO authors have written about his work a number of times: for example, “Debunking Suicide “Research” by Public Health Activists” (10/16/17) and “. . . And the Beat Goes On” (3/14/19). Tom Vaughan, MD wrote “New Public Database Reveals Bias of Gun-Control Researchers” (5/25/17), and upon receiving correspondence from Dr. Vaughan about that article, engaged in a productive email discussion with him. Dr. Vaughn wrote about their interaction in In “Let’s Talk About Guns” (10/24/17).

The RecoilTV interview was about Dr. Siegel’s recent publication, “The Meaning of Guns to Gun Owners in the U.S.: The 2019 National Lawful Use of Guns Survey”, which he wrote with Claire Boyne, JD, MPP, MA, also of Boston University School of Public Health. In it, they sought a “better understanding of the lawful use of guns and the symbolic meaning of guns to gun owners [in order] to bridge the divide in public opinion regarding policies to reduce gun violence in the U.S.” They surveyed a “national, prerecruited Internet panel of [2,086] U.S. adult [gun owners] in 2019 . . . to ascertain their gun-related attitudes and practices.” One wonders what a “prerecruited Internet panel” means (not likely a random, accurately representative sample, let alone considering the reasonable reluctance gun owners have developed about how they respond to surveys).

The meatiest findings were that the “majority of the gun owners viewed gun control advocates as wanting to take away all guns (58.5%). Nearly 70% of gun owners reported that a reason for their reluctance to engage in gun violence prevention was that they feel alienated because they perceive gun control advocates as blaming them for the gun violence problem, not understanding gun ownership, and not understanding much about guns.”

There are obvious, problematic assumptions just in the abstract. “Reluctance to engage in gun violence prevention” is not a problem among typical gun owners—they are the most safety-conscious people around guns. “Gun violence prevention” here suggests the sort of restrictions and legal requirements that have nothing to do with individual responsibility for safe gun ownership, and everything to do with the misapprehension that we need more control to keep society safe from us. Indeed, “Public health practitioners must develop novel communication strategies that avoid alienating gun owners by creating a perception that the ultimate aim is to take their guns away” because that “ultimate aim” is well understood, and certainly has alienated most of us.

I urge you to view the RecoilTV interview, because Dr. Siegel there demonstrated a real shift in the kind of opinions we’ve criticized in his previous work. He discussed his survey with evident sincerity about wanting to learn better what gun owners really feel and think.

So, I reached out to him via email. I pointed out problems about universal background checks and Red Flag laws, with which our readers are quite familiar, along with the rarely acknowledged necessity of including in any public health firearms study the thousands of lives likeliy saved by defensive gun uses, as shown by Gary Kleck, PhD and confirmed by the CDC. He still uses unfortunate terms like “gun violence” and “ assault weapons”, but I complimented him that that he clearly has “learned a lot about responsible gun owners & ownership” since his earlier work.

Dr. Siegel wrote right back, agreeing to do an interview or discussion for DRGO. He confirmed that he’s “learned a great deal about guns and gun ownership and that has changed [his] views in a number of ways.” He asked whether DRGO might be willing to collaborate in a “forum with gun owners and non-gun owners” to seek common ground toward reducing “gun violence” (well, there he goes again, but we would be pleased to try). He also sent me a full copy of the “2019 National Lawful Use of Guns Survey”, which I appreciated. He suggested possible times for an interview.

My fault came in not replying again for almost 2 weeks, but then I asked about some alternate times for our call. No reply. I wrote him again 3 weeks later. No reply since for the past couple of weeks.

I hope Dr. Siegel is not dead, incapacitated or kidnapped by terrorists. Otherwise, I have to wonder whether despite our agreeable introduction, someone got to him—about us at DRGO. When I met Liza Gold, MD, an academic psychiatrist who wrote a not very widely known book Gun Violence and Mental Illness, the first words out of her mouth were “I’ve heard about you guys.” (Ref: “Psychiatrist on Guns”). That was not intended as a compliment, although to us it actually is: we are recognized as a counterweight to mainstream ideology about firearms.

If you’re looking for academics who get it about guns, see: John Lott PhD; Gary Mauser PhD; Gary Kleck PhD; David Hardy, David Kopel & Stephen Halbrook, all JD’s; Miguel Faria, MD. There are plenty of others. Not to mention Doctors for Responsible Gun Ownership. We are proud to be in such distinguished company.

But this episode was disappointing. We’re glad to work with anyone who will face facts instead of fictions about firearms and their proper use. But we’re OK just doing that ourselves, with colleagues who have earned our respect. And that’s the way it is.

.

.

Robert B Young, MD

— DRGO Editor Robert B. Young, MD is a psychiatrist practicing in Pittsford, NY, an associate clinical professor at the University of Rochester School of Medicine, and a Distinguished Life Fellow of the American Psychiatric Association.

All DRGO articles by Robert B. Young, MD

When AK isn’t OK. Pt 2.

This time we go to Iraq where the Iraqi produced variants are a “pirated copy of a pirated copy” of the AK.

Imagine the Wish.com variant of the AK but then you got it through Limewire. Original internet explorers know about the Limewire… It you get double the quality control concerns of a pirated item. But at least this is a physical item so it will just explode or all apart instead of giving some com-bloc hacker the information saved on your computer. So that is nice.

Iraq licensed the Yugo. But the Yugo wasn’t licensed. It was picked up and reverse engineered. Now like any rifle, when it was well made it ran, Yugoslavia actually made theirs well. But the story devolves from their in the 80’s under the former Iraqi dictator, Saddam Hussein. (Haven’t heard that name in a minute, being dead and all will do that. But we’re talking history so he is back.)

What really spelled the failure of the Iraqi rifles was their cleaning and maintenance procedures… there aren’t any. This is typical of third world military and militia forces. Another common belief is that dialing a sight’s number up makes it shoot harder instead of being the distance for accurate shots in meters.. not like they use sights often though so they can believe as the wish.

In short, Iraq couldn’t follow directions have the Yugo engineers left and their product, like their economy at war, tanked.

Top Ten Reasons Why 2020 Was Not the Real Apocalypse tm

I actually made mother/daughter Xena costumes one year for Halloween. No you can’t see them.

I know it’s been a tough year. I know that the number “2020” has become a synonym for profanity – and it isn’t even over yet. But this wasn’t the “Big One”  – it wasn’t the Real Apocalypse we all prepped for. Just consider it a practice run. Look at it as an (albeit unpleasant) systems check.

Nonetheless this year has indeed sucked, so to cheer us all up and remind us that it isn’t all that bad even though it feels that way, here are my top ten reasons why this wasn’t the REAL APOCALYPSE tm:

10-My neighbors complimented my garden instead of stealing from it (or killing me over it).

9-You aren’t using leaves to wipe your butt. Stores are still open and you can still find toilet paper and some ridiculously priced ammo and canning supplies.

8-No zombies (unless politicians count).

7-I’m not using my rain barrel for drinking water. (And I’m still getting a water and sewage bill)

6-I’m not (yet) serving possum for Thanksgiving dinner.

5-I still have a medical practice with real medications and am not yet dispensing herbal remedies from my front porch like Claire from Outlander.

4-My credit card still works.

3-Amazon still delivers.

2-People still have their damn Christmas lights up before Thanksgiving.

And the number one reason how we know that 2020 was not the REAL APOCALYPSE tm

1-Politicians still exist and are STILL infringing on our rights.

2020 Votes are in. Self Protection is still gaining record popularity.

Now, these are Michigan numbers but as Michigan is a solidly politically middle state with our congress and governor often at odds (as this nation is likely to be for at least the next two years) is is probably a fair sample of attitudes.

As of November 2, 2020, there were 685,140 CPL holders in Michigan. That’s a gain of 9,600 CPL holders from the previous month. Not only is it an all-time record high, it is also the largest single monthly gain since MCRGO began compiling monthly numbers in 2008. MCRGO student certifications continue at the very high level we saw over the summer months. So we can anticipate more record growth over the late fall and winter. The full report can be read HERE.

The tally has it and CPL’s are at an all time record for the state. The dip we saw earlier this year wasn’t due to lack of demand but the fact that government offices were not fulfilling their duties in a timely manner due to lockdown and there were no alternatives built in.

People wanting a CPL to carry legally during this contentious time were denied their civil right, not for any legal reason, but simply because the government refused to do the paperwork they didn’t create a remote provision for. In the era where you can buy NFA items through that antiquated series of hoops almost entirely digitally, this was quite ridiculous.

But isolated government employees were eventually brought back in and appointments processed and a flood of new applicants came in who had been waiting. The larger counties have backlogs of a couple thousand applications.

What is also interesting is the number of expired licenses. I suspect we will see that pool shrink too moving into 2021. It’s a pile of people who forgot, haven’t been able to due to distancing restrictions or appointments, and those who just didn’t want to pay the rights tax this time.

In total 1.4 million Michiganders hold, held, or applied for a CPL license (685,140 are active with 25,609 pending pushing us over the 700k mark).

The people spoke, self protection is the way.

New Iron from Springfield Armory – Ronin 10mm

Springfield Armory is proud to introduce the Ronin 1911 in 10mm, a powerful and reliable pistol built for a lifetime of service at an MSRP of just $849.

The Ronin 1911 provides shooters with a pistol that combines classic styling with modern features, the result of thoroughly modern precision manufacturing mixed with a traditional approach to quality and performance.

Configured as a full-size 5″ gun, the 8+1 Ronin in 10mm features a forged steel slide and frame as well as a hammer-forged barrel for unparalleled durability and strength — ideal for a pistol harnessing the impressive power of the ever-popular 10mm cartridge.

1911 Ronin™ 10mm

Springfield Armory introduced us to the ‘Ronin’ line a little while back, and while the name seems to be a touch try-hard (but SAINT too) the pistols themselves rolled out as a line of no nonsense 1911’s.

Now the no nonsense 1911’s are offered in the “Best Millimeter” resurgent pistol powerhouse cartridge, 10mm. Not a lot of people carry 10mm, 9mm is the caliber of carry, but some do. More do in the context of hunting. Many choose a more energetic round if they have another limiting factory on them, such as capacity.

Regardless of your reason to validate the 10mm, it is arguably the 2nd most popular handgun caliber socially (if not in purchase format).

9mm – The stalwart everyman’s carry option. Good in many frames and for many many people.

45 ACP – An elegant caliber of a bygone era. Or slow fat bullet. Or MAh tWo WoRlD WArZ. Or some such other definition of the large caliber with the slow rolling recoil.

40S&W – Was king of calibers, until someone checked the math. ‘Midwestern spicy’ 10mm.

10mm – Best Millimeter. True king of calibers. Spicy but manageable, especially in alloy frames. Much beloved if rarely actually carried and shot.

380 ACP- Hobbit 9mm for when you want a gun that runs more finicky with less delivered energy and almost certainly more recoil due to lack of mass. A caliber, like many, that we ascribed attributes too that it really didn’t do.

“Is the M14 Rifle Obsolete?” – TFB

Yes. It is.

“Even in 6.5 Creedmoor?”

Yes, even in 6.5 Creedmoor.

Now, once again for the people in the back, the M14 or M1A rifles aren’t broken. They aren’t broken any more than the 7.62×51/.308 is ineffective. 7.62 is highly effective, and the M14 and M1A do work, they do run.

But they do not run as well as or conform easily today’s tech base and many many many platforms do. The M14/M1A was a heavy, wooden stocked, iron sighted, stripper clip fed, .30 caliber rifle that was made in an era where we knew it was suboptimal now. Even keeping iron sights and .308 we, the Americans, designed yesterday’s rifle and churned out what was a high maintenance piece of mediocrity compared to its peers.

The accuracy standard was 5.5 MOA and it was (is) a needy and expensive platform. That is the long and short of the story. Not that the rifle didn’t work but that there were already better ways to go about making the service rifle that the armed forces needed instead of the nostalgia piece they cobbled together with some lies about being able to make it on M1 tooling.

The services made it work because it was what they had. It did alright because it was built on sound past principles. It didn’t last because it was obsolescent the day it rolled of the line.

Turkey for the Lockdown Larder

No, not the wild kind. I’m talking about the kind you find frozen and shrink-wrapped at the grocery store.

I know I should be extolling the virtues of wild game in this space, but sometimes it just makes more sense to go farm-raised. This holiday season it seems that with large family gatherings being all but prohibited by law, the demand for the large turkeys is down.

Stores often do the loss-leader price thing for turkey anyway this time of year to get you into their aisles, but this year the bigger birds are deeply discounted in some areas because of lack of demand. I picked up two 15-pounders last weekend for 59 cents a pound. A friend of mine in a different state bought a couple birds for 39 cents a pound!

Why if I’ll only be feeding one or maybe two people over the holidays am I buying that big? Let me tell you.

-Money is tight for some families this year. Turkey is a great source of lean protein, and at 59 cents a pound, that’s hard to beat. We might as well stock up if we can.

-If you have the freezer space, this is also lockdown grocery insurance. It’s also job loss food insurance. Buy cheap now. Eat later even without a paycheck.

-If you don’t have freezer space, you can pressure can it and make the meat shelf stable for a couple years or more. 

This is what I’ll be doing. I’m using it as an excuse to finally get around to learning to pressure can meat. Stay tuned on that one.

Turkey jerky. I want to try it with my dehydrator not only for snacks, but also because the meat will take up a lot less space in the freezer as jerky.

-Broth, broth and more broth. Why buy cartons of commercial broth at the store, when you can make it yourself from the carcass for virtually no extra cost?  Just dump the bird carcass and bones in a big crockpot or roaster with water and a few onions and such and let it cook slowly for a day or two. (Yes, that long)

The broth  freezes well (or can be pressure canned) for later soups, gravy or rice. I make and freeze a lot of soup for my work lunches, so this is gold. Waste not want not.

So don’t let the Corona Fairy crap on your good mood for the 2020 holidays. Look at it as a low price opportunity to stock your meat supplies for what could turn out to be a long locked down winter. Then pull out your recipe box and get creative!